-
Website
http://www.fanblogs.com/ -
Original page
http://www.fanblogs.com/ncaa/007596.php -
Subscribe
All Comments -
Community
-
Top Commenters
-
Tom_Blogical
937 comments · 13 points
-
TigerEducated
1588 comments · 36 points
-
"BC"
747 comments · 29 points
-
TampaGator
901 comments · 55 points
-
Ramblin' Gator
1029 comments · 50 points
-
-
Popular Threads
-
Fanblogs Open Conference Championship Thread
2 days ago · 138 comments
-
Weis Out at Notre Dame
4 days ago · 114 comments
-
Week Thirteen College Football Polls
5 days ago · 53 comments
-
Fanblogs Turkey Day/Thanksblogging Thread
1 week ago · 76 comments
-
Alabama and Auburn Through The Decades
1 week ago · 70 comments
-
Fanblogs Open Conference Championship Thread
Texas 4 straight bowl wins
Cant wait for those TCU Frogs and Texas Tech Red Raiders to whup OU again like the last time they played them
Anyone looking to discuss Big12 penalties should head to bigxiiboards.com for team specific forums.
BTW Eric Dickerson didnt get his Pontiac from SMU
They had a great team, we played them .
Its all old stuff now, the Pontiac thing
BTW The car came from A&M boosters
did I make any allegations concerning any coaches.
The way I look at it, its all water under the bridge as to whether this happened
or that happened, you'll probably get over it eventually.
The main topic of the thread is NCAA violations right ?
Why would a particular coaches name even come up, heck I dunno
As a Texas fan I have alot of respect for our former adversaries
Hookem-Horns
Perhaps the NCAA can one day be as useful as the UN...
"…NCAA itself is doing a very poor job of actually uncovering infractions." (Well, there's a surprise for you.)
"…about two-thirds of all NCAA infraction cases are self-reported …More often than not, those who do not self-report do not get caught." (This one has me feeling like the AFLAC duck, after his experience with Yogi Berra.)
There it is, guys, your tax dollars at work. You know what else I know? You can't fry ice! But, I digress.
Try this for overstating the obvious. The penalties don't work because they target the wrong individuals or group. Whether discovered by the media, reported by a whistle blower, or self-identified by the school, if the infraction is egregious and sanctions are levied, the entire team is made to pay. This makes no sense.
I say, make those involved be made to pay. If it's a coach, member of the staff, or school employee, fire him. If it's an athlete, they lose the scholarship, a year of eligibility, and have to transfer to another school. Of course, even penalties that make sense won't work if nobody gets caught. OOPS, did it again. (Maybe I'll run for office.)
Alabama Won the SEC Championship in 1999
We went on probation in 2000
We are just now starting to recover in 2008.
Thanks NCAA.
PS - no university has control over their boosters. therefore, shouldn't be punished for their actions. the boosters themselves should be punished.
Why do you and all Bamers think that you are just now recovering. Didnt you have a chance to win the SEC 2 years ago after a 9-0 start only to get smoked by LSU and Auburn? Didnt all of us have to hear how Bama would win a National title in two years only to see the coach get fired?
Is a 6-6 record with a loss to your biggest rival and to lowly Lou Tech constitute a revival or any thing to get excited over?
Well reality never has been real high on most Bama fans list.
no. we never couldve won the NC with Mike Shula.
And why do i think we're starting to recover?
We have one of the top 5 head coaches in college football who took Louisiana State from 3-8 to the top program in the country.
He took a terrible Dolphins team and made them somewhat relevant (look what happened to them after Saban left).
Last year he took our team, laid the law down, some players didn't like it and played accordingly. BUT, he recruited the #1 class in the country last year, is working on another top 5 class, and has our team more united and driven towards winning.
Nick Saban has begun "the process" and i'm willing to give him at least a few years to make our team a BCS regular.
Now, that's being reasonable. I can't tell you how many Bama fans I've come across who revere Nick Saban as the 2nd coming. Your expectations make more sense. My hat's off to you.
Another FOUR of your players you signed are in deep academic doo-doo with the NCAA Clearinghouse, at least one of which is trying to explain away an extraordinary jump in ACT test score by claiming he is "Learning Disabled" and the new "unlimited" test time provision he was awarded by the LD disorder allowed him to improve his score 5+ points...
That #1 recruiting class ain't gonna be nowhere near #1 after you factor the attrition in. But, enjoy that "Mack Brown National Championship". Remember...You win actual National Championships in January in BCS Bowls...The ones that Rivals hands out are somewhat akin to that line from Top Gun by Val Kilmer...
"The Trophy for 2nd place is in the Ladies' Room"
'Bout time for you to take a powder and go admire it, by now, right BC?
because he was planning on losing some commits.
and like it or not mr. TE, but we got the most athletic class in the NATION last year. thats a fact. and i think we'll see around 5 of those guys start for us next year.
it seems like you're just upset because lowly Miles couldn't manage to land a top 10 class after winning the NC. thats just piss-poor recruiting.
we got a better class just for hiring Nick Saban (#10 in the country in 2007)
i mean you can say recruiting doesn't matter, but a study was done to find out whether Rivals.com ratings mattered, and the recruiting ratings were found to have a direct correlation to on-field success. Of course you must have a great coach to win on the field but i think we have that covered.
he's not like miles who will lose at least 2 games every season, even with the most talented team in the country.
Nick Saban's tenure at LSU:
2000 - 8-4
2001 - 10-3
2002- 8-5
2003 - 13-1
2004 - 9-3
Prior to LSU, he only had ONE season at Michigan State where he lost less than 4 games, which was his last, in 1999, when he left before their bowl game in over Florida, finishing at 9-2...
Saban averaged THREE losses/season at LSU, which is actually one game WORSE than Les has through three seasons.
I'm guessing you'll want to leave out his prior to LSU tenure (Because believe me, you don't want any of those other 5-6, or 6-5 seasons calcuated in from his time in East Lansing, and you DEFINITELY don't want last year's record in Tuscaloser factored in, either, because the loss #'s just keep going up).
BC, you might wanna learn to stop baiting me, kind sir...You usually end up worse for wear, bud...
Effin' Reggie Bush....
and plllease tell me how the university of alabama can control some rich and crazy alum that lives 7 hours from campus?? hell, i could go graduate from auburn, become part of the booster/alumni program?? then openly pay a big recruit, "accidently" get caught, and have auburn's program shut down for the next decade.......
hmmmm. haha
Only one school mentioned in that article was seriously being considered for the death penalty in that article referenced above...
Imagine if that would have come to pass. I truly would have felt sorry for the Tide, but felt sorrier for the SEC. I wonder what conference bylaws allow if a member is given the death penalty? I wonder if they can be kicked out of the conference?
Boosters should be punished, but if they paid for a guy like Terry Grant, Julio Jones, and John Parker Wilson to get on campus...What the HECK do you to do Alabama if a booster paid for those players to be there?
'Bama's now blameless, and so are the kids? He-double hockeysticks-TO THE NO!
Yeah...VERYYYYYYYY convenient opinion to hold after you got nailed to the wall for your reckless, completely out of touch with reality boosters...Which mirror the rest of your fanbase, only they've got discretionary incomes...
Off the reservation, out of touch, and hellbent that the NCAA is out to get them! Adjust that tinfoil helmet of yours, BC! It might hide that "do" of yours...
-TE-
if a booster wants Julio Jones to have a new Cadillac, i dont have a problem with it and neither should anyone else haha.
Because you're trying to promote education and scholarly work and achievement, which could pay dividends in your local area if the best & brightest of bulbs sticks around after graduation to start a career, family, and develop the community. It's a civic minded, philantrhopic end.
In collegiate athletics, it's all about amateur competition...on a level playing field...
I don't like schools like Catholic High or Parkview Baptist in Baton Rouge to participate against schools that are in the public system and "can't recruit". They're not playing on the same field...
If Arkansas or Oregon were allowed to use booster money to attract recruits, they'd compete for National Titles year in and year out...That's not fair to a school like LSU who may not have a Walton Family or a Phil Knight...
The Yankees win in pro sports because they throw so much money around...Same in the NFL...Though Oakland is a notable exception (they throw the benji's, but they have Al Davis' Joe Paterno-like aged and out of touch self doing the throwing)...
Collegiate athletics is the highest level of amateur athletic competition in our nation...
Why not significantly increase the penalty for those 1/3 of the teams that do not self report. The honest mistakes will self report, and a stiff penalty for not catching your own mistakes would keep mistakes honest.
As for senators wasting time, isn't that what they do? Ever watched C-SPAN-2?
Remember, that'll only happen, as long as OK doesn't play WVU.
(Just yanking your chain, Lennie.)
What's weird is, after beating Switzer & company in Norman, WVU barely beat MD, the following week 28-27, when MD went for the win with a 2 pt conversion and blew it. Go figure.